Unfortunately for my bank account, I'm a confirmed "early-adopter." If it's new and fairly affordable, I want one, and I want it now. The latest device to get my attention is the Amazon Kindle 2.0.
E-Books aren't new to me. I've owned two Sony e-Readers, the PRS-500, and then the PRS-505. I resisted buying the original Kindle even though some of its features I found very impressive. With all the hype about the newest version of the Kindle, version 2.0, I felt I had to at least give it a try. As with so many of my previous purchases, I was comfortable knowing there was always E-Bay. If I don't like it, sell it. So, when the Kindle was announced on February 9, I went to the Amazon website and placed the order.
After a week or so, I thought better of the order and decided to stick with the Sony. Of course, that didn't last long. As I watched the other early-adopters report on their new toys, I again placed an order for the Kindle and the leather cover. Two days later, on Friday February 27, I returned to my office to find the new Kindle and Cole-Haan cover on my desk.
I've been using the Kindle for a little over 24 hours now, and I wanted to share a few of my first impressions. Of course, the killer feature was the first to show its shine. Ordering wirelessly using Sprint's Whispernet is, without a doubt, the feature that sets the Amazon Kindle and the Sony e-Reader apart. I charged the Kindle battery for about 3 hours and once fully charged I started ordering books and newspapers from the online store. All worked exactly as advertised. After the orders were placed and confirmed, the material appeared on the device within one to two minutes. Impressive!
As for fit and finish, the Kindle doesn't come anywhere close to the Sony. Compared to the e-Reader, the Kindle feels like a toy. It is mostly white plastic, except for the metal plate on the back. Everything fits together nicely, and I guess if weight is the primary consideration, lightweight plastic might be the material of choice. But, compared the the sturdy feeling Sony, the Kindle doesn't feel as substantial. And, while much has been made of the new button design on the Amazon entry, I don't care much for them. In fairness, they might be much better than the original. I never owned or used the original version, but compared to the Sony, it's often for me a hit-and-miss proposition when buttons are pushed. While the Kindle buttons appear flat on the surface of the device, it appears you have to put the buttons on the left hand side, rather than in the middle. I'm hopeful it's due to the fact I've only used the device for a short period, or maybe it will be easier to manipulate after it's been "broken in" for awhile.
Based on what I've experienced after only 24 hours, if I had to make a choice, I guess it would have to be the Amazon Kindle 2.0. As I mentioned earlier, the ability to order wirelessly -- no matter where you are -- is the feature I find most useful. For this reason only, the Kindle should win a battle of electronic books. The technology in the two devices is in all other ways, almost identical. I like the way the Sony e-Reader is constructed and is certainly a more sturdy device, but having to connect the device to your computer to transfer purchased books from the Sony Store is a step that makes it inconvenient.
I don't know what Sony is working on, but I would strongly suggest they develop a wireless method of transferring purchases to the e-Reader. If not, I'm guessing they'll have to get out of the electronic book market in the very near future. On the other hand, I find their physical device preferable in every other way.
Oh, and as for the Cole Haan leather case -- do yourself a favor and look for other options. Both the outer leather cover, and the suede-like material on the inside is very nice. My complaint is primarily with the system to attach the cover to the Kindle. For the price of $99, you get a nice leather cover that attaches to the $359 device by four ribbons of elastic! While I've only had it for one day, I already envision the Kindle becoming undone from the elastic and crashing to the floor, destroying my expensive tech toy.
There are certainly better ways to anchor an expensive toy, such as the Kindle, to a leather case better than this. And, based on what I've seen so far, most manufacturers of Kindle covers use the same attachment system. Only the Amazon-branded cover seems to securely hold the Kindle in place, and while it's cover is faux leather, my guess is that it will protect the device to a greater degree than it's $99 counterpart.
And of course, my Dooney and Bourke cover for the Sony e-Reader is nicer than anything I've seen for the Kindle.